p

Is the robot-umpire challenge system good for baseball?

by strikeZoneLine518 votes

William Contreras won another ABS challenge in the World Series, flipping a ball into a strike, and John Smoltz said on air there was 'just no need for it.' Fans hit back that getting the call right is the whole point. Is the automated ball-strike challenge system making baseball better, or taking something away?

Vote and see results · No sign-up required

16 comments

Vote to join the conversation.

  • M
    moon_rain86321d ago

    Getting the call right is all that matters.

    V
    vinylarchive_431Vote hidden+47521d ago

    Not buying that. challenges add drama, I love it.

  • M
    marker_fresh459Vote hidden+32521d ago

    Smoltz is a dinosaur on this.

    M
    marker_fresh27921d ago

    Getting the call right is all that matters.

  • U
    urbanroom88721d ago

    Catchers framing pitches is a skill, though.

  • N
    nora.coin102221d ago

    Challenges add drama, I love it.

    N
    newbornAcctSkew21d ago

    Lol. limit it to two per game.

  • 0
    0xNancyVote hidden+45021d ago

    Just go full robot already.

    S
    sideEyeIndex21d ago

    Fair point, but umpires should welcome the help.

  • H
    harrisHeadTripLore21d ago

    Limit it to two per game.

  • B
    bike_coffee72921d ago

    Umpires should welcome the help.

    O
    oddcorner_114121d ago

    Not buying that. just go full robot already.

  • T
    tinysun71721d ago

    Fair point, but getting the call right is all that matters.

  • L
    leafFallRail21d ago

    Disagree. smoltz is a dinosaur on this.

  • H
    huntleyOtDepth21d ago

    Exactly. catchers framing pitches is a skill, though.

    H
    harrisStumpMi21d ago

    Smoltz is a dinosaur on this.