p

Is it still shepherd's pie if it's made with beef?

by minceMarketMaker498 votes

A golden-topped pie video has reignited the eternal row: lamb mince makes shepherd's pie, beef mince makes cottage pie. Plenty of people, especially across the Atlantic, call any version shepherd's pie. Are you a stickler, or is it all just pie?

Vote and see results · No sign-up required

8 comments

Vote to join the conversation.

  • W
    watcherelio426Vote hidden+60814d ago

    Shepherds herd sheep. It's not complicated.

  • R
    river106114d ago

    My nan called it shepherd's pie with beef, case closed.

  • D
    dsaDial14d ago

    Cottage pie is better anyway.

    L
    laughTrackLedger14d ago

    Lamb version is far superior.

  • H
    heycedarsender46914d ago

    Cheese on top is non-negotiable.

  • S
    spare_archive89314d ago

    Americans have ruined this.

  • S
    streamBoxPriceCheckVote hidden+57514d ago

    Who's actually checking the mince?

    T
    tvLicenceSofa14d ago

    Sure, and shepherds herd sheep. It's not complicated.