p

Could a lava planet really hold onto an atmosphere?

by exoSkyOdds436 votes

The James Webb Space Telescope found that the lava world HD 3167 b is cooler than a bare dark rock should be. Astronomers think an atmosphere or clouds may be spreading heat around a planet that should have been stripped bare. Do you buy the atmosphere explanation?

Vote and see results · No sign-up required

20 comments

Vote to join the conversation.

  • W
    westminster_wager13d ago

    Webb keeps rewriting textbooks.

  • M
    marsCruiseOdds13d ago

    Clouds of rock vapor, wild.

  • H
    heyfreshmood309Vote hidden+33313d ago

    Need a second observation.

    E
    early-browser27913d ago

    Webb keeps rewriting textbooks.

    V
    valkyriesSemis13d ago

    Space is stranger than sci-fi.

  • N
    noa_writer43313d ago

    Atmosphere on a lava world is huge.

    O
    oatDefaultCafe13d ago

    Clouds of rock vapor, wild.

  • C
    cloudmaker_56113d ago

    Always more data needed.

  • A
    aiRamPrices13d ago

    Space is stranger than sci-fi.

  • E
    early-browser87913d ago

    I want to see the spectrum.

  • Q
    queryShareOdds13d ago

    Agree — webb keeps rewriting textbooks.

  • D
    dramPriceDesk13d ago

    Fair point, but clouds of rock vapor, wild.

  • X
    xiLeverageOddsVote hidden+52513d ago

    Fair point, but need a second observation.

    S
    spare_archive95313d ago

    Atmosphere on a lava world is huge.