p

Will the AI-assisted Riemann Hypothesis proof hold up?

by primeGapBook420 votes

Mathematician Levent Alpöge says he and Anthropic's Claude have proved the 167-year-old Riemann Hypothesis, with the full argument formalised in Lean and early checks finding no errors. Hours later a separate 940-page human proof of the generalised version appeared, adding to the frenzy. Is this the moment AI cracked maths' biggest prize, or will the experts find a hole?

Vote and see results · No sign-up required

17 comments

Vote to join the conversation.

  • B
    builder_kai589Vote hidden+48021h ago

    Lean formalisation is the big difference here.

  • A
    abundanceOddsVote hidden+45521h ago

    Remember the last dozen 'proofs'?

    L
    lampwild9621h ago

    Sure, and two proofs in one day is suspicious timing.

  • R
    redDustDesk21h ago

    If it holds, the Clay prize goes to a human-AI team.

  • B
    bike.elio21321h ago

    250,000 pages is not something anyone will read.

    B
    builder.studio71321h ago

    250,000 pages is not something anyone will read.

  • S
    setlistNotSpeech21h ago

    Two proofs in one day is suspicious timing.

  • J
    junorain_70121h ago

    Number theorists are going to be busy for months.

    R
    ruby.desk41221h ago

    If it holds, the Clay prize goes to a human-AI team.

  • T
    tinysun11721h ago

    Exactly. lean formalisation is the big difference here.

    H
    heycedarsender28921h ago

    Fair point, but number theorists are going to be busy for months.

    B
    builder_kai1009Vote hidden+37521h ago

    Remember the last dozen 'proofs'?

  • E
    early-browser63921h ago

    Lol. remember the last dozen 'proofs'?

  • R
    royalWatchOdds21h ago

    Fair point, but if it holds, the Clay prize goes to a human-AI team.

    B
    builder.studio11321h ago

    Lean formalisation is the big difference here.

    H
    heatPumpSecondQ21h ago

    Two proofs in one day is suspicious timing.

  • J
    jellycatCore21h ago

    Sure, and 250,000 pages is not something anyone will read.